Featured image: U.S. Navy littoral combat ship USS Santa Barbara sails in formation with Philippine Coast Guard vessel BRP Malabrigo, the Japanese destroyer JS Yudachi and Philippine Navy frigate BRP Antonio Luna in the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone, July 24, 2026. File photo. Photo: Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Caylen McCutcheon, U.S. Navy, Wikimedia Commons, public domain. Cropped to 16:9.
A Philippine Coast Guard admiral and a Chinese professor clashed over Ayungin Shoal at the Manila Dialogue on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, in an exchange heated enough that the moderator repeatedly asked them to stop. Rear Adm. Jay Tarriela, the coast guard’s spokesperson for the West Philippine Sea, rejected the scholar’s claim that the shoal, known internationally as Second Thomas Shoal, is Chinese territory.
Zheng Zhihua, an associate professor at Shanghai Jiao Tong University Unverified claim, Zheng Zhihua, Shanghai Jiao Tong University (Chinese state university; views echo Beijing's position), argued that the Philippines had occupied the feature for more than 27 years and defended China’s use of water cannons against Philippine vessels, BNC reported. “As a big power, I think if other country occupy your land territory, you only use water cannon to defend your territorial integrity,” Zheng said, according to BNC. GMA News quoted a slightly different version of the remark.
“The last time I checked”
“I would just like to correct you in saying that China does not have any territorial jurisdiction whatsoever in Second Thomas Shoal,” Tarriela said. “The last time I checked, Second Thomas Shoal only has a distance of 125 nautical miles from the Philippines. And it is our exclusive economic zone, not China’s,” he added, according to GMA News.
Zheng countered that Manila was inconsistent. “You claim Second Thomas Shoal is territorial in nature for a couple of times. Where Philippines thinks it’s convenient, it’s called EEZ,” he said, BNC reported. Panel moderator Ray Powell intervened repeatedly to end the back-and-forth. The exchange, also reported by ABS-CBN News, came during a discussion of whether a proposed China-ASEAN Code of Conduct for the South China Sea should be legally binding. Zheng said a code would be ineffective without a fundamental consensus between China and ASEAN members.
Data: where Ayungin sits

Under the U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea, an exclusive economic zone extends up to 200 nautical miles from a country’s baselines. At the 125 nautical miles Tarriela cited, Ayungin lies at about 63% of that limit, by Boston Report calculation. In July 2016, an arbitral tribunal under the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled for the Philippines, rejecting China’s nine-dash-line claims and finding that Second Thomas Shoal, Mischief Reef and Reed Bank lie within the Philippines’ EEZ and continental shelf. The ruling declared Ayungin a low-tide elevation. China did not take part and rejects the ruling, GMA News noted.
ASEAN’s role
Indonesian scholar Dewi Fortuna Anwar redirected the panel, saying ASEAN might need to intervene to defuse tensions and that China should reach out to member states rather than assert its power. “To jeopardize the goodwills of ASEAN countries over these issues in the South China Sea, I think is, you know, you are shooting your foot,” she said, according to GMA News.
For background, read our report on the Ayungin Shoal medical evacuation and our tracker of Philippines-China incidents in the South China Sea. Follow the story on our Philippines news page and get more military news.
Sources
- GMA News: Tarriela rebuts Chinese scholar’s claim that Ayungin Shoal is Chinese territory (Nov. 17, 2026)
- BNC: Heated exchange erupts between Tarriela, Chinese professor over Ayungin (Nov. 2026)
- ABS-CBN News: Tarriela, Chinese academic clash over Ayungin Shoal during Manila Dialogue (Nov. 16, 2026)
Read next in Asia-Pacific
Most read this week
- Finland Confirms Strike on Russian Warship in Gulf of Finland; Ukraine’s SBU Claims Drone Attack
- U.S. Envoys Witkoff and Kushner Hold Talks With Putin in Moscow, Then Head to Dublin to Brief Zelensky
- Israeli Strike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital Kills Six, Including a Surgeon, Health Ministry Says
- Nvidia Earnings, Walmart and Fed Minutes Headline a Busy Week for Wall Street: What to Watch Nov. 16-20
- Iran’s Ghalibaf Says Hormuz Will ‘Never Return’ to Pre-War Status as Another Tanker Is Hit
Latest
- Navy Extends $219 Million Isa Air Base Support Contract as Iran Targets the Bahrain Base
- Lithuania Hands U.S. a Permanent Base Proposal as Army Battalions Return to Pabradė
- Russia’s Northern Fleet Drills Against a Beach Landing as a Norwegian Patrol Plane Flies Near Murmansk
- Haiti Gang Leader Threatens Port-au-Prince Fuel Depots as Forces Push Near the Airport
- SOUTHCOM Chief Watches Marines Fire Live Rounds at Guantanamo as Cuba Stages Defense Drills
Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy


