Judge Orders ICE to Free Plymouth Detainee Held 15 Months

A Boston judge ordered ICE to release a Haitian man held 15 months in ICE detention in Plymouth by Nov. 20. The government asked the court to reconsider.

Share this article

Featured image: The John Joseph Moakley United States Courthouse in Boston, where U.S. District Judge Richard G. Stearns is hearing the habeas case (file photo, September 2024; not from this case). Photo: 4300streetcar, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0. Cropped to 16:9.

A Boston federal judge has ordered immigration officials to release a Haitian man held in ICE detention at the Plymouth County House of Correction for more than 15 months, with a deadline of close of business Friday, Nov. 20, unless the court changes that order. U.S. District Judge Richard G. Stearns ruled on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that Kervens Datus, 24, had “plausibly established that there is no significant likelihood of his removal in the reasonably foreseeable future.” On Thursday, the government asked Stearns to reconsider, arguing that a different detention statute applies because Datus has appealed a November 2025 removal order and that appeal is still pending.

Advertisement
In ICE detention since
Aug. 13, 2025
Plymouth County House of Correction
Days in custody
464
as of Nov. 20, TBR calculation
Release deadline
Nov. 20
close of business, unless changed
Government motion
Nov. 19
asks the judge to reconsider

What the judge ordered

Stearns’s Nov. 18 electronic order is short. After stating that Datus had made that showing, the judge wrote: “The government having declined to the court’s invitation to file a rebuttal, see Dkt # 15, the court orders Datus released by close of business Friday, November 20, 2026.” He directed the government to file a notice on the docket confirming compliance no later than Monday, Nov. 23.

The case is Datus v. Moniz, No. 1:26-cv-13379, in the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. Datus filed the habeas petition himself on July 23. The petition names Antone Moniz, the superintendent of the Plymouth County Correctional Facility, and federal officials as respondents. They are represented by Assistant U.S. Attorney Benjamin Tolkoff of the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Boston, part of the Trump administration.

Universal Hub, which first reported the Nov. 18 order, identified Datus as a Roslindale resident and a graduate of Madison Park Technical Vocational High School. Those details do not appear in the judge’s written orders.

As of 10 a.m. Eastern Time on Friday, Nov. 20, public dockets on CourtListener and Habeas Dockets still showed no numbered filing after the government’s Nov. 19 motion to reconsider. CourtListener listed that motion as the latest document and gave a last-known-filing date of Nov. 19, 2026; the site said it last collected the docket from PACER at 6 p.m. Eastern on Nov. 19. Habeas Dockets likewise listed last activity as Nov. 19 and displayed a bare “Order on Motion for Reconsideration” label with no judge’s text and no document. No notice that Datus has been released appeared on those public dockets. Universal Hub had not updated its Nov. 18 report, and no Boston Globe story on the case was found. This article does not report that the judge has ruled on the motion or that Datus has been released.

Why the government says the order should be withdrawn

In a two-page motion filed Nov. 19, the government said Datus “is not yet subject to a final order of removal and his detention is governed by 8 U.S.C. § 1226, not § 1231.” It said he was ordered removed from the United States in November 2025, appealed that order to the Board of Immigration Appeals, and that the appeal “is still pending.”

“He is not being held because the government is struggling to remove him,” the motion said. “He is being detained pending the resolution of an appeal that he filed and could withdraw at any time he chooses.” Until the appeal is resolved, the government argued, the removal order is not final and the framework in the Supreme Court’s decision in Zadvydas v. Davis does not apply. If the appeal is later denied, the motion said, “it is highly likely that … he will be removed without delay.”

The motion was filed for U.S. Attorney Leah B. Foley and attached a removal order, a Board of Immigration Appeals appeal receipt, and the August 2026 bond hearing order — records the court had asked about on Nov. 4, when it noted it had not seen a copy of the removal order.

How the case reached a Friday deadline

Stearns first addressed the petition on July 31. He wrote that Datus, “a 24-year-old citizen of Haiti who has been in custody at the Plymouth County House of Correction since August 13, 2025,” was entitled to a bond hearing, and he ordered that a hearing be held no later than Aug. 4, consistent with the First Circuit’s decision in Hernandez-Lara v. Lyons.

The government later reported that an immigration judge denied bond “in response to the criminal allegations against him, primarily the restraining order issued against him on motion by a family member,” Stearns wrote in an Aug. 28 order, citing a government status report. Those are allegations, not findings of guilt in the federal case. Datus wrote to the court that the hearing did not meet due process requirements. Stearns said he lacked jurisdiction to review that claim until Datus appealed the bond denial to the Board of Immigration Appeals, and he stayed the case for that appeal.

On Nov. 4, Stearns returned to the length of the detention. He noted that no appeal of the bond denial had been taken, that the government represented there was an order of removal, and that the remaining claim was governed by Zadvydas. He asked the government to reply within 10 days “as to the significant likelihood of removal in the reasonably foreseeable future and, because Datus is pro se, whether he has appealed the Removal Order.” No reply was filed in that period. On Nov. 18, Stearns issued the release order, writing that the government had “declined to the court’s invitation to file a rebuttal.” The reconsideration motion, with the exhibits, was filed the next day.

Advertisement
Date What happened
Aug. 13, 2025 Datus is taken into custody at the Plymouth County House of Correction, according to Stearns’s orders.
November 2025 The government says an immigration judge ordered him removed; it later said he appealed to the Board of Immigration Appeals.
July 23, 2026 Datus files a habeas petition in Boston federal court, acting as his own lawyer.
July 31–Aug. 28 Stearns orders a bond hearing by Aug. 4. Bond is denied. The judge stays the case so Datus can appeal that denial; the court later said no such appeal was taken.
Nov. 4 The court asks the government to reply within 10 days on the likelihood of removal and whether the removal order was appealed.
Nov. 18 With no timely reply on file, Stearns orders Datus released by close of business Nov. 20.
Nov. 19 The government moves to reconsider and files the removal order and a Board of Immigration Appeals appeal receipt.
Sources: electronic orders and filings in Datus v. Moniz, 1:26-cv-13379 (D. Mass.), via CourtListener.

By the numbers: 15 months in ICE detention

Datus has been in custody at Plymouth since Aug. 13, 2025, according to Stearns’s orders. As of the Nov. 20 deadline, that is 464 days, or about 15 months and a week, by a Boston Report calculation from those dates. The six-month period the Supreme Court described as a presumptively reasonable term of detention after a final removal order would run 184 days from that start date, to about Feb. 13, 2026. Datus’s time in custody is about 2.5 times that six-month mark and 280 days longer, also by a Boston Report calculation. Those figures describe the length of detention. They do not resolve the government’s argument that Zadvydas does not apply until a removal order is final.

Bar chart comparing the 184-day presumptive six-month period under Zadvydas with 464 days in ICE detention at Plymouth as of the Nov. 20, 2026, release deadline
Days in ICE detention calculated by The Boston Report from the Aug. 13, 2025, start date in Judge Stearns’s orders. The six-month bar is the presumptive period described in Zadvydas v. Davis (2001) after a final removal order. The government argues that framework does not apply while a Board of Immigration Appeals challenge is pending. Sources: Datus v. Moniz docket; Zadvydas v. Davis, 533 U.S. 678 (2001); chart: The Boston Report.

In Zadvydas v. Davis (2001), the Supreme Court held that, after a final removal order, detention is presumptively reasonable for six months. After that, if the person shows good reason to believe removal is not significantly likely in the reasonably foreseeable future, the government must rebut that showing. Six months does not automatically require release if removal remains reasonably foreseeable. Stearns applied that framework in the Nov. 18 order. The government says the order of removal is not final because of the pending appeal, so detention during removal proceedings, under a different statute, governs instead.

The Plymouth County House of Correction holds ICE detainees under a contract with the federal government. In November 2024, the Boston Globe reported that the contract had been renewed through September 2029. Universal Hub has described the jail as the only one in Massachusetts that still accepts ICE detainees. Datus remains there unless and until the Nov. 18 order is carried out or changed.

For more on immigration enforcement in Massachusetts communities, see our earlier report on Chelsea schools adding staff at dismissal after reports of ICE agents near campuses, and our Boston crime and public safety news.

Related: ICE has made 28 arrests at Massachusetts courthouses since the PROTECT Act took effect, the Trial Court says.

Sources

Read next in Crime & Law

Get The Boston Report Briefing

Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy

Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sign up