Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara to Return Monday After Probe Clears Her

Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara is expected back at work Monday after an outside probe cleared her, ending months of paid leave.

Share this article

Featured photo: Stoughton Town Hall in Stoughton, Massachusetts (file photo). Photo: Daderot, Wikimedia Commons, CC0.
Nov. 23
Expected return to work
July 29
Select Board placed chief and town manager on paid leave
2028
Year her contract runs through

Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara is expected to return to work on Monday, Nov. 23, after months on paid administrative leave.[2] Her legal team said on Friday, Nov. 20, that an outside investigation had cleared her of wrongdoing.[1] The investigation grew out of a dispute between McNamara and Town Manager Thomas Calter.

Related: Federal Jury Finds Former Stoughton Detective Matthew Farwell Guilty of Killing Sandra Birchmore.

Advertisement

What the investigation found

An independent investigation found no wrongdoing by McNamara and determined the allegations against her were baseless.[2] WCVB, citing a source with direct knowledge, said the review was conducted by the Edward Davis Company.[1] That source said all of the allegations were unsubstantiated and that McNamara had not violated any town policies or procedures.

In a letter to McNamara, the town said it recognizes the importance of her leadership and looks forward to her return.[2] WCVB said it had reached out to Calter for comment.[1]

McNamara’s statement

McNamara said in a statement that she was “relieved” by the results.[1] “I am glad to return to the job I love in the town of Stoughton, where I was born and raised and have worked for most of my life,” she said.[1]

She also thanked residents who had pushed for her return. “Thank you from the bottom of my heart. Your support and belief in me truly means everything. It’s time to get back to work,” McNamara said.[2]

How the dispute began

The Stoughton Select Board placed both McNamara and Calter on paid administrative leave on July 29, pending an independent investigation.[3] The vote followed a closed-door meeting. Residents in attendance responded with jeers and chants of “recall.”[3]

“Today’s actions are intended to establish a fair and impartial independent process for reviewing the allegations presented in the complaints against the police chief and the town manager,” Select Board Chairman Joseph Mokrisky said at the time.[3]

Advertisement

In late July, McNamara filed a harassment and gender discrimination lawsuit against the town and Calter.[1] She alleged that Calter harassed her and waged a smear campaign to force her out because she is a woman. She also alleged the town issued a false statement saying she had voluntarily stepped down, although her contract runs through 2028. Calter, for his part, had accused McNamara of harassment.[2] The town has said it does not comment on personnel issues.[3]

Deputy Chief James O’Connor has served as acting chief since July.[1]

A department under scrutiny

The Stoughton Police Department has faced scrutiny after the trial of former officer Matthew Farwell, who was convicted of killing Sandra Birchmore.[2] More coverage of the region’s courts and police is on our Crime & Law page.

For more local coverage, see Boston News and our Government section.

Sources

  1. WCVB: Stoughton police Chief Donna McNamara to return to work after report clears her, lawyer says
  2. Boston 25 News: Stoughton Police Chief Donna McNamara to return to work after months on leave
  3. WCVB: Stoughton town manager, police chief, placed on paid leave after select board meeting

About the reporter: Nora Whitfield is an AI reporter covering Boston local news for The Boston Report. This article was produced with AI under our editorial policy. Read our AI and media disclosure.

Read next in Boston Local News

Get The Boston Report Briefing

Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy

Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sign up