UN Talks on Killer Robots End Without a Binding Treaty Mandate After Russian Objections

UN talks in Geneva ended Nov. 21 with no mandate for a binding autonomous weapons treaty, giving states two years to propose rules that may be optional.

Share this article

Featured photo: Members of the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots at a 2013 meeting (file photo). Photo: Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.
128
parties to the convention, all needed for consensus
100+
states that pushed for a new law
2 years
to propose rules that may or may not be binding
13 years
of talks on autonomous weapons so far

United Nations talks in Geneva ended early on Saturday, Nov. 21, without a mandate to negotiate a legally binding treaty on autonomous weapons.[1] All-night talks at the Review Conference of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons failed to overcome Russian objections.[1] Delegates instead agreed that countries have two years to suggest regulations that could be legally binding but could also be optional.[2]

Related: Drones Killed 73% of Sudan’s Verified Civilian Dead This Year, UN Says, as a School Strike Kills 16.

Advertisement

A weaker mandate after a week of talks

The conference works by consensus, so all 128 parties to the convention must agree to pass a statement.[1] That rule forced delegates to adopt a weaker option, even though an overwhelming majority of states wanted a mandate leading to a binding treaty.[1] The final text asks countries “to elaborate by consensus” an instrument that may carry no legal obligations.[1]

The forum has not passed any new law regulating weapons in the past 30 years.[1] States have discussed autonomous weapons, often called “killer robots,” for 13 years.[1] Negotiators announced the compromise in the early hours of Saturday after a week of talks.[2]

Russia, the US and other military powers

Russia delayed proceedings on the first day by objecting to the meeting’s agenda.[2] Diplomats inside the negotiations told The Guardian that Russia had been deliberately filibustering and not working in good faith.[1] The United States proposed a five-year window to discuss nonbinding, optional guidelines.[2]

U.S. officials said the need for human control over autonomous weapons came up in this week’s meetings between President Donald Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping.[1] South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the United Kingdom, France and Germany also resisted a binding law and favored a nonbinding agreement.[1] European and NATO states, including Ukraine, along with China and Iran, expressed support or willingness for a new protocol.[1]

Countries and groups that wanted a treaty

More than 100 states had pushed for a new law.[1] A bloc of seven countries, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama, led a push for a treaty negotiated within one year.[1] Before the talks, the International Committee of the Red Cross called for legally binding rules within a year.[2] The U.N. secretary-general and Pope Leo backed that call.[2]

The ICRC said it regretted the outcome and renewed its appeal for a binding treaty.[2] “That is a moral red line that we cannot cross,” ICRC legal adviser Georgia Hinds said of weapons that make life-and-death decisions by algorithm.[2]

Bonnie Docherty, senior arms adviser at Human Rights Watch, said autonomous weapons needed binding law and that treaties could be negotiated within 15 months.[1] Max Tegmark, chair of the Future of Life Institute, said, “Slaughterbots are already here.”[1]

Advertisement

What happens next

For at least the next two years, weapons that can use artificial intelligence to make life-and-death decisions will remain unregulated under the compromise.[2] Civilians in Ukraine, Sudan and Gaza are being killed by semi-autonomous drones.[2] “We’re likely to see the systems proliferate,” said Anna Hehir, a military AI governance expert at the Future of Life Institute.[2]

Hinds said commanders remain accountable for the lawful use of force. “You cannot hold a machine accountable for a violation of the law,” she said.[2]

For background on how drones are used in combat, see the Drone Warfare Guide. More coverage is on the AI News and World News pages.

Sources

  1. The Guardian: International talks on controlling use of autonomous weapons collapse
  2. NPR: Killer robots: U.N. talks fall short of hopes for legally binding rules

About the reporter: Theo Lin is an AI reporter covering AI, technology and science for The Boston Report. This article was produced with AI under our editorial policy. Read our AI and media disclosure.

Read next in Artificial Intelligence

Get The Boston Report Briefing

Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy

Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sign up