A federal appeals court ruled on Friday, Nov. 20, that the House passed the $1.7 trillion government funding bill of 2022 unconstitutionally, because it relied on a pandemic-era rule that let lawmakers vote by proxy instead of in person.[1] The full 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, based in New Orleans, split 9-8.[1] The practical effect is narrow for now: the ruling keeps in place an order that bars federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the state of Texas.[1]
Related: Jeffries Wins Speaker Nod 251-11 as Clark Takes No. 2.
What the court decided
The majority held that proxy votes do not count toward the quorum the Constitution requires before the House can do business.[2] In the court’s reading, the Quorum Clause requires a majority of House members to be physically present to pass legislation.[1] Judge Cory Wilson, an appointee of President Donald Trump, wrote the majority opinion. He said the House’s broad power over its own procedures does not let it get around the clause’s limits.[1]
The majority also said the government had not shown that an emergency existed when the House adopted proxy voting.[2]
The bill passed the House 225-201, with one member voting present.[2] According to the opinion, 226 lawmakers cast their votes by proxy.[2] President Joe Biden signed it into law.[1]
Why the effect is limited, for now
The court did not void the whole spending law. Its relief bars the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant workers provision against Texas.[1] The opinion stressed what it called the ruling’s “narrow scope.”[2]
The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act requires some employers to provide accommodations to pregnant workers.[2] The same 2022 bill also funded federal agencies and included roughly $45 billion in emergency aid for Ukraine and NATO allies and about $40 billion for disaster relief.[2]
Inimai Chettiar, president of the workers’ rights group A Better Balance, which worked with lawmakers on the provision, told CNN the harm could reach further. She said trial judges across the states covered by the 5th Circuit could cite the opinion if a pregnant worker sued after being denied an accommodation.[2]
The dissent
Judge James Graves, an appointee of President Barack Obama, called the ruling “illogical, inexplicable, and invalid.”[1] He said the majority read a physical-presence requirement into the Constitution that is not there.[1] He also noted that no member objected at the time that a quorum was lacking.[2] And he asked why, if the whole law was passed unconstitutionally, the court limited its ruling to one small piece of it.[1]
How the case got here
- May 2020: The House, led by Speaker Nancy Pelosi, adopted proxy voting as an emergency measure after the COVID-19 pandemic began.[1]
- Late 2022: Before Republicans took control of the House, it used the rule to pass the spending package. Republicans dropped proxy voting when they took over after the November 2022 elections.[1]
- 2023: Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued to block the pregnant workers law in Texas.[2]
- District court: A federal trial judge sided with Texas. A split three-judge 5th Circuit panel then reversed that decision.[3]
- En banc review: Texas asked the full court to rehear the case, which led to Friday’s 9-8 ruling.[3][1]
Paxton recently lost his bid for the U.S. Senate.[2]
What happens next
The federal government can ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the decision, and lawyers following the case had expected it could end up there.[3] If the law were ultimately struck down, Congress could pass it again.[3] Legal experts have warned that a ruling against the law’s passage could affect other bills the House passed with proxy votes.[2] Follow the high court on our Supreme Court News page, and more on Capitol Hill under Congress and Politics.
Sources
- NBC News: House unconstitutionally passed spending bill in 2022, appeals court rules
- CNN, via Yahoo News: Biden-era spending law found unconstitutional by federal appeals court
- Parker Poe: Full Fifth Circuit To Review Constitutional Challenge to Pregnant Workers Fairness Act
Read next in Crime & Law
Most read this week
- Nvidia Earnings, Walmart and Fed Minutes Headline a Busy Week for Wall Street: What to Watch Nov. 16-20
- Strait of Hormuz Insurance Rates Explained: What War-Risk Cover Costs in 2026
- Rare Earth Truce Explained: What the Jan. 10 Deadline Means
- Video of an Austin Mosque Prayer Spreads With a Violent Translation; the Wording and Its Target Are Unverified
- MIT Checks a Claimed Riemann Hypothesis Proof as 175,187 Lean Files Compile Without Errors
Latest
- $1,000 Fines and Utility Crews: Mass. Move Over Law Expansion Heads Back to the House
- ICE Boston Blames PROTECT Act for a Worcester Release as 12 of 14 Sheriffs Press Healey
- Massachusetts Adds 7,500 Jobs in October as Unemployment Rate Falls to 4.2%
- 3 Medford Police Officers Hurt in Intentionally Set Crescent Street House Fire; 1 in Custody
- Boston Weather: Up to 2 Inches of Rain Tonight, Then a Thanksgiving Nor’easter Meets 11.8-Foot Tides
Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy


