Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton told the House Homeland Security Committee on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that the string of outages that hit airlines, banks, Microsoft and the National Security Agency in the past week were separate technical failures, not a coordinated or state-sponsored cyberattack.[1] He testified at the committee’s annual worldwide threats hearing, titled “Worldwide Threats to the Homeland: 25 Years After 9/11,” alongside Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia.[1][3] Clayton also said threats of lethal plotting by Iran inside and outside the United States have risen sharply, and he faced pointed questions from Democrats who said he was not giving straight answers.[1][2]
Related: NSA Network Outage Feeds Hack Fears, but Officials Say It Was Maintenance, Not a Cyberattack.
What Clayton said about the outages
Clayton said intelligence officials reviewed the incidents with other agencies and with private-sector cybersecurity experts and found no sign they were linked.[1] “These are separate service outages associated with maintenance and technical changes,” he said, adding that they were not a coordinated or state-sponsored attack.[1] He told lawmakers the timing understandably raised questions and that Americans were right to ask them.[2]
Asked why he was sure, Clayton said he had a “very high level of confidence” because each outage had a different cause and none showed the techniques, tactics and procedures seen in past hacking campaigns.[2] Mullin and Raia gave the same assessment. Raia said FBI cyber specialists had examined the incidents from the start and found no indication of malicious cyber activity.[1] The FAA suspects last week’s ground stop was caused by a newly installed router at a remote radio site in Arkansas.[2]
Warnings on AI, aging systems and FISA
Clayton warned that what he called superintelligence is sharply increasing the speed, scale and sophistication of both offensive and defensive cyber operations, and said the change reaches the battlefield and commerce as well as cybersecurity.[3] He said fast gains in computing power are making government systems that were considered old six months or a year ago much older, a point he raised while explaining why systems fail.[1][3]
He also urged Congress not to let Section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act expire, calling it the “single most indispensable tool” for early warning of foreign threats to the homeland and U.S. troops.[3] Clayton said he would not discuss classified intelligence in an open hearing and noted that full briefings had gone to the Gang of Eight and the intelligence committees.[3]
Iran and other threats
Clayton said threats of lethal plotting by Iran, both inside and outside the United States, have substantially increased.[1][2] He did not address questions about CNN’s report this week that U.S. intelligence indicates Iran is planning a possible dirty bomb or chemical weapons attack in Washington aimed at senior officials. CNN has reported that officials are divided over whether Iran can or will carry out such an attack.[2] None of the officials publicly confirmed that the reported plans were operational or that Iranian sleeper cells were preparing attacks in the U.S.[1]
Rep. Michael Guest, a Mississippi Republican, asked about sleeper cells, and Mullin said the threat was a concern DHS fights every day.[1] Raia said much of the reporting on possible plots is “largely aspirational” but is still taken seriously.[1] Clayton separately pointed to online radicalization by foreign extremist networks of people already living in the U.S., citing a case in New York.[1]
Concerns lawmakers raised
Straight answers on the NSA outage. Rep. Dan Goldman, a New York Democrat, repeatedly asked Clayton whether the NSA’s network failure on Monday came from internal software and hardware work. Clayton said there was no indication it came from external threat actors and described routine patches, upgrades and hardware swaps. Goldman told him he was clearly not answering the direct question.[1]
The FBI director’s absence. Committee Chairman Andrew Garbarino, a New York Republican, criticized FBI Director Kash Patel for not testifying, saying Patel had been given the date in August and that skipping the hearing broke with committee precedent.[2]
Mullin’s football trip. Ranking Democrat Bennie Thompson of Mississippi criticized Mullin for flying to the LSU-Texas football game on Saturday while more than a million Americans were still dealing with the fallout of the FAA ground stop. Mullin defended the trip and accused lawmakers of hypocrisy. Rep. Mike McCaul, a Texas Republican, praised Mullin’s response to the ground stop.[2]
Domestic terrorism and political direction. Thompson pressed Raia to name a right-wing group that might qualify as a domestic terror threat. Raia cited Antifa as an example of a group but declined to name any right-wing organization. Raia also said President Donald Trump has never directed the FBI to investigate or not investigate anyone.[2]
ICE hiring and the Nvidia case. Mullin said he had restored training for new Immigration and Customs Enforcement recruits that was cut under his predecessor, Kristi Noem. Asked about the Nvidia investigations, he said DHS was not involved and learned of the matter only when it became public.[2]
What happens next
Clayton said the intelligence community will keep watching for malicious cyber activity aimed at U.S. networks.[2] CNN has asked the FBI for comment on Patel’s absence.[2] Follow which incidents were real hacks on our Major U.S. Hacks Tracker, see official advisories on our Security Threat Warnings page, and read our report on the GAO’s covert tests of AI chatbots.
Sources
- CBS News: “No indication” outages are related to cyberattacks, officials say
- CNN: Mullin testifies about tech outages: Live hearing updates
- Fox News: Recent service outages not state-sponsored attacks, DNI Jay Clayton testifies
Read next in Technology
TechnologyNSA Network Outage Feeds Hack Fears, but Officials Say It Was Maintenance, Not a Cyberattack
TechnologyThe FAA, Microsoft and Big Banks All Failed in One Week. Officials Say None Were Cyberattacks. Here Is What Is Still Unexplained
Artificial IntelligenceGAO Says ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Grok All Produced U.S. Attack Plans in Covert Tests
Most read this week
- Finland Confirms Strike on Russian Warship in Gulf of Finland; Ukraine’s SBU Claims Drone Attack
- U.S. Envoys Witkoff and Kushner Hold Talks With Putin in Moscow, Then Head to Dublin to Brief Zelensky
- Israeli Strike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital Kills Six, Including a Surgeon, Health Ministry Says
- Nvidia Earnings, Walmart and Fed Minutes Headline a Busy Week for Wall Street: What to Watch Nov. 16-20
- Iran’s Ghalibaf Says Hormuz Will ‘Never Return’ to Pre-War Status as Another Tanker Is Hit
Latest
- Video of an Austin Mosque Prayer Spreads With a Violent Translation; the Wording and Its Target Are Unverified
- World Court Rules Thursday on Myanmar Genocide Case as Fears Grow of U.S. Sanctions on Its Judges
- Nvidia Stops Shipping Hopper AI Chips to China, Including the H200, Days After Jensen Huang’s Exit
- Trump and Putin Shake Hands in Shenzhen, Their First Meeting Since Alaska, a Day Before Talks With Xi
- Worrell and Culpepper Ask Healey to Halt Blue Hill Avenue Bus Lane Project and Order New Studies
Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy