MTA Says EAGLE Fare Inspectors Violated Policy in Two Videos; Some Face Discipline Up to Firing

MTA officials said some MTA EAGLE teams inspectors face discipline up to firing after two videos of clashes with bus riders, and the squads remain suspended.

Share this article

Featured image: a New York City Transit bus in a January 2023 file photo. Photo: GK tramrunner RU, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Cropped to 16:9.

New York City Transit President Demetrius Crichlow said Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, that an investigation into two recorded clashes between the Metropolitan Transportation Authority’s EAGLE fare-inspection teams and bus riders found the conduct “unacceptable” and in violation of agency policy. Some inspectors, he said, face internal charges that could include termination.

Advertisement

The unarmed civilian squads — formally the Evasion and Graffiti Lawlessness Eradication Teams — remain suspended from fare inspections, an order MTA Chair and CEO Janno Lieber issued after the videos became public. Crichlow said the agency still intends to keep using fare inspectors, even as it changes how the teams work.

Inspectors
About 350
Crichlow, via amNewYork, Nov. 16, 2026
Incidents under review
2
Videos from Brooklyn and the Bronx
Local bus fare evasion, Q1 2026
48.2%
MTA estimate, as reported by CBS New York in May
2024 bus fares lost
$315 million
MTA figure, via CBS New York, tied to nearly 1 million unpaid boardings

What Crichlow told the MTA board

Speaking at Monday’s MTA Board New York City Transit Committee meeting, Crichlow said he had opened the investigation late last month after videos of the two incidents circulated. “What was captured on the video during these two incidents was unacceptable,” he said, according to amNewYork. “It violates the policies and values of New York City Transit and is not in line with my values for delivering service and safety for our employees or for our customers. As a result, charges have been drafted against select individuals, and those charges could end up in discipline up to and including termination.”

An MTA spokesperson told amNewYork the charges are internal, not criminal. Crichlow said he would detail the findings in a letter to Lieber. The newspaper said it had requested that letter and had not received it at the time of publication.

In one incident early last month, amNewYork reported, surveillance video from a nearby store showed several EAGLE team members throwing Brooklyn public school aide Kyle Taylor against a bus shelter. Taylor’s attorney said the confrontation began after Taylor paid his fare with a paper transfer and refused to show identification, and that inspectors then punched him in the face and threw him to the ground, injuring him in several places. Those details are the attorney’s account, as reported by amNewYork; the MTA has not, in the coverage reviewed for this article, released a detailed public findings report on that incident.

The second incident, the newspaper said, was recorded in the Bronx in August and showed fare agents surrounding an unidentified man, throwing him to the ground and restraining him.

What the authority says will change — and what will not

Crichlow said the operations review has included retraining the roughly 350 inspectors in de-escalation, “emotional intelligence” and “effective communications.” He also said the agency will test a body-worn camera pilot, issue new uniforms and open a hotline for riders to report fare-inspector incidents.

He did not say the teams would be abolished. “It is critical that we still have a means of fare enforcement in our system,” Crichlow said, according to amNewYork. “No question that folks should pay their fare in order to ride the system. Without their fares, the system doesn’t run.”

Advertisement

The newspaper reported that those comments run counter to recent calls from the City Council’s 23-member Progressive Caucus and from the advocacy group Riders Alliance to scrap the EAGLE teams altogether. The incidents also came as the MTA was piloting handheld devices meant to check OMNY tap-and-pay fares.

What the fare-evasion figures show

The MTA has pointed to unpaid bus rides as the reason the teams exist. In a May 22, 2026, CBS New York report on a related onboard-inspection pilot, the station said the MTA estimated that fare evasion on local New York City buses was 48.2% in the first quarter of 2026. The same report said the authority estimated that in 2024 nearly one million people boarded buses without paying, translating to $315 million in lost bus fares.

Those are MTA estimates, reported by CBS New York in May, not a new figure released at Monday’s meeting. A 48.2% evasion rate would mean that, in the MTA’s first-quarter 2026 estimate, nearly one in two local-bus rides was unpaid. The agency’s $3 local-bus fare, cited in the amNewYork account, is the price those unpaid rides would have been charged. This article does not have a later official quarterly update from Monday’s meeting to show whether the rate has moved since the first quarter.

The EAGLE debate is one of several New York City enforcement fights this week. Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Commissioner Jessica Tisch agreed on Monday to disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, and on Tuesday the mayor outlined a transition plan for horse-carriage workers ahead of a 2028 industry ban.

Sources

Read next in Government

Get The Boston Report Briefing

Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy

Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sign up