Plymouth and a Native Group Go Before a Judge Monday Over the Day of Mourning Stage

A Native American group and Plymouth go before a judge Monday over a stage and insurance for the National Day of Mourning on Thanksgiving.

Share this article

Featured photo: the Massasoit statue on Coles Hill in Plymouth, where the National Day of Mourning gathers each Thanksgiving, December 2007 (file photo). Photo: Greg Kullberg, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.
Monday
both sides due before a judge
1998
year of the agreement at issue
3-2
Select Board vote upholding the insurance demand
Nov. 26
Thanksgiving, the day of the observance

The United American Indians of New England (UAINE) has gone to court to force the town of Plymouth to set up a stage for its annual National Day of Mourning without first requiring insurance.[1] Lawyers for both sides are due before a judge on Monday, Nov. 23, three days before Thanksgiving.[1] Plymouth Town Manager Derick Brindisi said the observance will go ahead as scheduled on Thanksgiving Day, WBZ-TV reported.[1]

Related: Plymouth’s Thanksgiving Parade Steps Off at 10 a.m. Saturday From Plymouth Rock.

Advertisement

What the dispute is about

UAINE has held the Day of Mourning on Coles Hill every Thanksgiving since 1970.[2] A clash with Plymouth police at the 1997 event led to a 1998 agreement that let the observance continue.[1] That agreement lets participants gather and march without a permit, and it does not mention insurance.[2]

The town now says it will not set up the event’s stage unless UAINE provides a certificate of insurance or hires an outside vendor.[1] The town’s own mobile stage has fallen into disrepair and is no longer in service.[2]

“When we learned of this stage set up on state property, we realized that there was increased liability and increased risk,” Brindisi told WBZ-TV.[1]

Jean-Luc Pierite, president of the North American Indian Center of Boston, said the groups want the original terms restored. “We want the town to return to the original terms of the agreement and provide the staging as it was done from 2014 until 2025 without incident,” he told WBZ-TV.[1]

How the Select Board voted

The Plymouth Select Board voted 5-0 in a closed-door session on Nov. 10 to authorize town counsel to seek a deal requiring UAINE to secure insurance for the staging.[2] The board upheld that position 3-2 in another closed session on Tuesday, Nov. 17.[2] The decision drew a protest outside Town Hall and a long line of critical speakers at that evening’s meeting.[2]

In the Tuesday session, board member Bill Keohan moved for the town to pay for the insurance and supply a stage, and Richard Quintal seconded it.[2] Chair Deb Iaquinto and members Kevin Canty and David Golden voted it down.[2] The coverage was estimated at just a few hundred dollars.[2] Quintal said he then offered to pay for it himself through his charitable nonprofit.[2]

An offer to pay for the stage

Olly deMacedo, longtime director of America’s Hometown Thanksgiving Celebration, offered to pay the insurance bill and provide a portable stage, the Plymouth Independent reported.[2] As of late Thursday, Nov. 19, UAINE leaders had not responded to him or to town officials.[2] Iaquinto said she would not comment on the offer until UAINE replied.[2]

Advertisement

The second year of the fight

This is the second straight year the town and UAINE have clashed over the 1998 deal.[2] Last year, officials sought to require coverage, UAINE sued, and the town backed down.[2] The two sides then revised the agreement.[2] The accounts differ on what that revision means. WBZ-TV reported that last year’s changes ended the town’s duty to set up the stage without an insurance certificate.[1] The Plymouth Independent reported that the revised text says the town will “facilitate, prepare, and enable” the observance consistent with practice since 1998.[2]

About two dozen people, including Native American elders, were arrested at the 1997 protest.[2] The town dropped the charges under the 1998 settlement, which also placed a plaque on Coles Hill near the statue of the Wampanoag leader Massasoit.[2]

More South Shore coverage is on our Boston news and New England pages.

Sources

  1. CBS News Boston (WBZ-TV): Native American group’s dispute with Plymouth over National Day of Mourning heads to court
  2. Plymouth Independent: Parade director offers a way to end Day of Mourning standoff

About the reporter: Nora Whitfield is an AI reporter covering Boston and New England news for The Boston Report. This article was produced with AI under our editorial policy. Read our AI and media disclosure.

Read next in Boston Local News

Get The Boston Report Briefing

Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy

Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sign up