ICE Boston Blames PROTECT Act for a Worcester Release as 12 of 14 Sheriffs Press Healey

ICE Boston said Nov. 19 the PROTECT Act forced a Worcester jail release, as 12 of 14 sheriffs wait on Gov. Healey over pretrial ICE notice. What we know.

Share this article

Featured photo: The Massachusetts State House in Boston (file photo, August 2022). Photo: Hunter Bloor, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Boston field office said in a news release on Thursday, Nov. 19, that the Worcester County Sheriff’s Office had to release a man ICE wanted to deport because of the state’s PROTECT Act. ICE said its officers later arrested him in Worcester on Nov. 10. The agency used the case to back a request from 12 of the state’s 14 county sheriffs, who want Gov. Maura Healey to change how the law treats people jailed before trial.[1]

12 of 14
county sheriffs signed the letter to Healey
Nov. 10
ICE arrest in Worcester, per ICE
Under $1,000
bail for pretrial detainees cited by sheriffs
3
Dukes County pretrial releases in 2026 that sheriffs flagged

Related: ICE Has Made 28 Arrests at Massachusetts Courthouses Since the PROTECT Act Took Effect, Trial Court Says.

Advertisement

What ICE says happened in Worcester

ICE said the man, whom it described as a citizen of the Dominican Republic, has convictions for home invasion and for assault and battery with a dangerous weapon causing serious bodily injury, and that he was sentenced to 10 to 12 years for them. ICE also said he faces a pending charge of assault and battery on a correctional facility employee, and that an immigration judge ordered him removed on March 5, 2025. The Boston Report is not naming him. The pending charge has not been decided, and he is presumed innocent of it.[1]

The release does not say why he was in the sheriff’s custody before he was let go, or whether he was being held before trial or after a sentence. That detail matters under the law, as the next section explains. ICE said its officers arrested him shortly after the release.[1]

“Time and time again, sanctuary politicians in Massachusetts have made the dumbfounding choice,” acting ICE Boston Field Office Director Joseph Sher said in the release. He added that ICE Boston would keep arresting people whom state officials would not turn over.[1]

What the sheriffs are asking for

In a letter in late October, 12 of the 14 sheriffs asked Healey to consider a change that would let their offices notify ICE about people who are charged with violent crimes and subject to deportation orders. The signers were 10 Democrats and two Republicans. The PROTECT Act broadly bars sheriffs from telling ICE in advance before they release someone the agency wants to deport. The one exception covers people who have completed a sentence for certain violent felonies, and the sheriffs’ letter said that exception does not apply to pretrial detainees.[2]

Barnstable County Sheriff Donna Buckley and Middlesex County Sheriff Peter Koutoujian did not sign. The letter said four sheriffs’ offices were holding pretrial detainees with immigration detainers, all charged with a violent or dangerous offense and all with bail set below $1,000. The sheriffs asked for a “legislative, regulatory, or administrative solution” that would allow limited notice in those cases.[3]

Dukes County Sheriff Robert Ogden told the Martha’s Vineyard Times that Healey met with her staff, Attorney General Andrea Campbell’s office and sheriffs’ association leaders, and then asked the sheriffs three questions. Ogden said his office reported three pretrial releases in 2026 on charges that would have qualified had the people been sentenced: cocaine trafficking with $650 bail, possession to distribute a Class B drug with $10,000 bail, and kidnapping with assault and battery with a dangerous weapon with $1,500 bail. His office also reported that none of the people in its custody with ICE detainers had prior convictions for the felonies listed in the law. Ogden said the sheriffs had not heard back since sending their answers and that no amendment had been drafted.[3]

Advertisement

How Healey has responded

Healey has defended the law. When the letter became public in late October, she called ICE a “rogue agency” and said she would keep talking with the sheriffs.[2] Her spokesperson, Jacqueline Manning, told the Vineyard Times that the governor will keep working with sheriffs to address public safety concerns.[3]

The dispute came up during the governor’s race. Republican nominee Mike Minogue raised the letter, and Healey’s campaign later announced endorsements from the state’s 12 Democratic sheriffs. Hampshire County Sheriff Patrick Cahillane, president of the Massachusetts Sheriffs Association, then wrote to Healey that the sheriffs never meant the request to become partisan.[2]

A separate fight over courthouse arrests

Immigrant advocates are pressing the state from the other side. They say ICE has made civil arrests at courthouses without the judicial warrant the law requires. Healey’s office said on Nov. 18 that it had referred reports of possible PROTECT Act violations to the attorney general’s office. A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson cited the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause and defended courthouse arrests.[4] For more on state and city responses to federal immigration enforcement, see our politics coverage and Boston local news.

Sources

  1. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement: ICE Boston arrests criminal alien felon from the Dominican Republic (Nov. 19, 2026)
  2. WBUR: Mass. sheriffs ask Gov. Healey to tweak new limits on ICE arrests (Oct. 29, 2026)
  3. The Martha’s Vineyard Times: Balancing public safety in the age of ICE (Nov. 17, 2026)
  4. Boston.com: Immigrant advocates increase pressure on officials after reports that ICE is ignoring PROTECT Act (Nov. 18, 2026)

About the reporter: Marcus Hale is an AI reporter covering politics, courts and national news for The Boston Report. This article was produced with AI under our editorial policy. Read our AI and media disclosure.

Read next in Boston Local News

Get The Boston Report Briefing

Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.

Free. We never sell your address. Privacy policy

Get The Boston Report Briefing
Our free weekly email with the most important stories from Boston and the world. Unsubscribe anytime.
Sign up