Illustration of two rival football helmets facing each other over a snowy stadium split by a road map of the AFC East, Patriots vs Bills

Patriots vs Bills: AFC East Race and the Next Three Seasons

by

Key takeaways

  • Buffalo leads the AFC East at 3-1 and New England is 2-2, with the Patriots holding the head-to-head edge after their 29-26 win on Oct. 4. The teams meet again on Dec. 6 at Gillette Stadium (4:25 p.m. ET, CBS).
  • Allen is signed through 2030 on a $330 million extension; Over the Cap lists Maye’s cap hits at $9.99 million in 2026 and $11.66 million in 2027, and Spotrac shows the Patriots with roughly $37 million of 2026 cap space.
  • The Bills have $5.0 million of 2026 cap space and a projected 2027 shortfall on Over the Cap; the Patriots reached last season’s Super Bowl as AFC champions.
  • Everything labeled analysis is our projection and could change with injuries, trades and results.

The AFC East has two teams with different timelines. Buffalo built its recent run around Josh Allen and is now in a coaching transition, while New England, the defending AFC champions, is developing a young quarterback under Mike Vrabel. This report compares them using public records as of Oct. 11 and then offers labeled projections for the next three seasons.

The standings and the head-to-head

Buffalo is 3-1 and New England is 2-2, according to Pro Football Reference’s game logs. The Patriots lost 13-10 at Seattle, beat Pittsburgh 20-3, lost 35-6 at Jacksonville and then won at Buffalo, becoming the first team to win in the Bills’ new stadium, per Patriots.com. The Patriots hold the head-to-head tiebreaker edge for now, and the second game is Dec. 6 at Gillette Stadium. In the same stretch the Patriots face the Jets twice (Oct. 18 at home and Dec. 27 on the road) and Miami twice, on Nov. 1 and in a home finale whose date is to be determined; Buffalo plays Miami on Nov. 22 and Jan. 3 and the Jets on Nov. 15 and in Week 18, per each club’s schedule.

Two quarterback contracts

Allen’s extension runs through 2030 and totals $330 million, per AP, and Over the Cap lists cap hits of $44.228 million in 2026, $56.148 million in 2027 and $62.364 million in 2028. Drake Maye is on a rookie contract with 2026 and 2027 cap hits of $9.99 million and $11.66 million per Spotrac; Over the Cap lists a possible fifth-year option price of $25.836 million. The difference in what each team pays its quarterback is one of the largest structural gaps between them, and it is covered in more detail in our Patriots preview.

Cap and roster flexibility

Spotrac lists roughly $37.2 million to $37.5 million of 2026 cap space for the Patriots, and Over the Cap lists $34.7 million. For Buffalo, Over the Cap lists $5.04 million of 2026 space and $47.4 million of dead money, and shows 2027 commitments exceeding the cap. Buffalo’s coach changed in January, when Joe Brady replaced Sean McDermott, with Jim Leonhard coordinating a rebuilt defense, per AP. New England has Vrabel and is tracking injuries on its offensive line, covered in our reports on the Van Roten and Onwenu injured-reserve moves.

Analysis: three scenarios

This section is our analysis and projection, not reporting. None of it is a prediction by either team.

  • 2026: Buffalo’s 3-1 start and early lead make it the likelier division winner on paper, but the margin is a single game and the Dec. 6 rematch could decide the tiebreaker. A New England win would give the Patriots the head-to-head sweep, which matters if the teams finish with the same record.
  • 2027: Buffalo’s public cap numbers tighten, which in our view makes the offseason the main test of how the front office balances Allen’s contract with other starters. The Patriots, with a low-cost quarterback and cap room, have more flexibility to add players, though the team has to decide whether to exercise the option on Maye.
  • 2028: If both quarterbacks stay healthy, the structural gap in cap flexibility could favor New England, but we would not make that a certainty: drafts, injuries and coaching changes have historically altered NFL timelines much faster than contract tables suggest.

What would change this outlook

Injuries to either quarterback, especially Maye’s right shoulder, which appears on the Patriots’ injury report, or the Bills’ offensive line, would change these projections quickly. A long-term extension for Maye, a restructure or release of veterans in Buffalo, and each club’s draft capital are the other variables. We have not factored in trade rumors or unreported contract terms.

Sources

More: Boston sports news.